- Dina Reviews, Looking at TV and Film
On Gaiman and Sandman…
- November 22, 2026
Hey, I’m back to talking about Sandman!

It’s been a while since I did… and a few disturbing revelations have come up about Neil Gaiman since then. You may have heard it… multiple women have accused Gaiman of sexual misconduct… some of the stories of him and his now ex-wife Amanda Palmer are pretty wild… non-con BDSM, borderline sex slavery… human trafficking?
While Gaiman hasn’t had any formal criminal charges against him, and some of the accusations do seem a little out-there… I think we can safely say that Neil Gaiman has proved that he’s not quite the good guy I thought he was. I’ll just repost here what I said on Bluesky when the news first broke about his former live-in nanny accusing him of sexual misconduct:
So. Apparently Neil Gaiman is accused of sexual assault. Tried to read a bit about the case (not listening to that podcast, sorry…) and… um… gotta say, even if it WAS consensual it sounds… kinda iffy? ..actually, it sounds a lot like those romance trash novels I read when I was 15. You know, the “romance” novels with at least three graphic sex scenes in them where at least one is dub-con at best. I ate those books up as a horny teen, but I don’t think I ever viewed them as something I’d want to happen in real life.
In any case… I get that Neil Gaiman had this open relationship thing going on, but it’s PROBABLY a bad idea to fuck your much-younger fans. Or the nanny you hired to take care of your child. Even if they do consent, and even if they are of age… that sort of thing I think should stay in fiction land.
For the record: I get that my erotic hypno comics and stories aren’t the picture of safe, sane and consensual. But even the ones that are somewhat based on certain real-life events are still fiction… a couple were my way of processing things that happened to me or ALMOST happened to me. Let’s just say, a naïve 19 year old who expresses an interest in erotic hypnosis meets lots of skeevy dudes… it’s one reason why most of my hypnodomme chars are women. They just feel safer.
Also, I get that I usually have myself as the victim, so with me it’s probably a different kind of fantasy altogether. But it’s still not something I’d enjoy in real life. I like to think I can distinguish between fantasy and reality.
Not to say that I don’t occasionally get the attack of “I’M SICK NORMAL PEOPLE DON’T FANTASIZE ABOUT THIS” feelings of guilt and paranoia. My fantasies can get DARK. But really… my base belief is that fantasy is fantasy. It’s only a problem if you try to turn it into reality. And it seems like Neil Gaiman forgot he wasn’t actually the love interest in a romance trash BDSM novel.
Mind you, I wrote this back in 2024, when these accusations had barely started. Since then, more women came out with accusations against Gaiman, it has been claimed several places that Gaiman’s predatory behaviour has been an “open secret” in certain literary and fan spaces, and he and Amanda Palmer were accused of rape, sexual assault, and human trafficking via labour exploitation.
Gaiman himself has denied many of these claims, insisting that any sexual relationship he had with any women were 100% consensual, but he admitted that he was probably a difficult person to deal with — “emotionally unavailable,” “self-focused,” and “careless with people’s hearts and feelings.” He did, however, call the accusations against him a smear campaign. And call the former live-in nanny a “fantasist” who had fabricated a tale of abuse for financial leverage. Apparently he had logs and WhatsApp conversations that proved that it was all consensual, buuuut… now we’re kind of going into the “she wanted it!” defence and that seldom leads anywhere productive.
(And anyone who now starts going “weeeell, TECHNICALLY, in 2026 Scarlett Pavlovich’s case against Gaiman was dismissed”, just FUCK OFF. That dismissal was on jurisdictional grounds, not because the allegations were proven false. IT DOESN’T MAKE IT OKAY JUST BECAUSE IT HAPPENED IN NEW ZEALAND INSTEAD OF AMERICA!)
However, the entertainment industry responded by totally cancelling the guy. Most adaptations of Gaiman works that were in the running have been cancelled or cut short; the planned third season of Good Omens was reduced to a movie finale, the Anansi Boys comic series was cancelled, the Coraline stage musical has been shut down, the Graveyard Book movie will probably never see the light of day… and of course The Sandman Netflix show was done after two seasons. (And I don’t care what the showrunners said, the original comic had enough material that they could easily have made three seasons.)
Now, in the latter case, the second season was in the last stages of filming before the allegations came out, and, well, it’s Netflix, isn’t it? In the last few years, the number of series that HAVEN’T been cancelled after two seasons are pretty rare. So in this case it may be less about Gaiman and more about the fact that it’s Netflix. But still, the way Gaiman had become persona non grata for the entertainment world definitely has everything to do with how the advertising for the second season was nearly non-existent.
But…. though I won’t pretend this hasn’t seen a blow to my fangirlish little heart, and I won’t ever be able to look at this series quite the same way again… I still ended up watching the second season of the show. Because even with all this, I don’t think Sandman has been AS ruined by the Gaiman revelations as Harry Potter has been ruined by JKR’s rampant transphobia.
Don’t get me wrong, Gaiman’s legacy has been shot to hell, and he probably deserved it. I don’t think all those women just made stuff up. But unlike with Harry Potter, where JKR has held onto the rights so tightly that the series has stagnated and was running on empty fumes long before those disastrous Fantastic Beasts movies… Sandman is not, and has never truly been, JUST Neil Gaiman’s baby. Sure, he was the writer and the main ideas man, he developed the concepts and it’s his voice that’s strongest. But there were always other voices there. Sam Kieth. Mike Dringenberg. Jill Thompson. Karen Berger. And the universe expanded with other voices and other stories. I still like The Books of Magic series that John Ney Rieber and Peter Gross developed after Gaiman’s four-issue miniseries (seriously, I know this isn’t the common opinion, but the ongoing is much better than the miniseries!), and which gave me a lot of inspiration when it came to my interpretation of the Fae… and Mike Carey’s Lucifer spin-off was also really good, as was the Netflix series based on that comic (even if the series had basically nothing to do with the source material, and the entire thing has become more a police procedural with supernatural elements, Tom Ellis is just so damn charming as Lucifer).
And of course Gaiman, even with his “I was the victim of a smear campaign and she totally asked for it” response, at least hasn’t gone out and boasted in social media that he’ll use any profits from Sandman to continue harassing women, nor has he contributed to sexual harassment becoming more acceptable to the point where sexual harassment laws have been questioned and it has been made easier to sexually harass women under the guise of “protecting men”. JKR has been very open about how she’ll use any HP profits she gets to harass trans people, and her attacks on trans people has made it easier to discriminate against trans people and legally get away with it; even laws protecting trans rights have been questioned and overturned because of JKR. Who celebrated by posting a picture of herself smoking a cigar on X-Twit with the comment “I love when a plan comes together”. Gaiman may be a creep. but JKR is a fucking Bond villain.
So yeah… I refuse to touch any official HP merch again; I stick with unofficial LGBTQ-friendly fan works that don’t bring a penny into that disgusting TERF’s pockets (and even there I’m moving away… but that’s a discussion for another time). But like I said, I DID watch the second season of Sandman. And you might call me a disgusting hypocrite and say that I’m enabling an abuser. Maybe I am. And I won’t make arguments like “separate the art from the artist” like everyone’s saying these days, because honestly… what does that phrase even mean anymore? It’s been used so much and in so many contexts that you can use it to excuse almost everything.
But, after all this… what did I think of the second season of the Sandman show?
It felt horribly rushed. Not that it didn’t have some good moments… it had PLENTY of good moments, in fact. But it rushed from plot point to plot point, ignoring large parts of the story, making the story feel much smaller than it should be. The Season of Mists storyline, where Lucifer closes down Hell and gives Dream the key, and he is visited by a huge number of deities from different mythologies who all want the key to Hell… it’s great high-concept stuff but it feels so small and contained. Hell is CLOSED, all the damned souls have left and are roaming the Earth. And what do we see of that? ABSOLUTELY NOTHING. There are a few throwaway lines but otherwise no indication that this has any effect on anything or anyone. I mean, in the comic all we really got was an issue about a horrible boarding school where old dead students returned from Hell, tormented the living and complained about how nobody in Hell had taken them seriously… but that was at least SOMETHING, Here, there was NOTHING.
That is a recurring problem with the Netflix series, really. Big cosmic events are kind of just… downplayed and made to seem like they didn’t actually affect anything. Even the first season had this problem with John Dee’s supposed torment of humanity when he has Dream’s ruby; while his psychological torment of the people in the diner is on display, there is no indication that anything unusual is going on outside that diner, outside a couple of throwaway lines and a shot of a burning street. This half-hearted inability to commit to either keeping things small OR keep them big and universal is probably the biggest weakness of the series… and it’s there in full force in season two.
Perhaps most disappointing is that they skipped the A Game of You story entirely. I mean, the A Game of You story had its problems, but skipping it meant no Barbie and no Wanda… okay, sure, they had a character named Wanda in the show but it was really just Ruby the cab driver who was given Wanda’s name, some of her traits, her transgender identity and her crappy family. Skipping A Game of You and almost all the minor stories meant we have less time in the Dreaming, less time with the characters, and Nuala’s story was cut short. I mean, she was supposed to be staying in the Dreaming for a long while, but here just a couple of eps pass and then it’s “LOL just kidding come back to Faerie!” The entire thing is made less poignant and feels more shallow because they’re rushing so much… yes, Nuala HAS to end up staying in the Dreaming, and she HAS to be taken back to Faerie again, because those events are vital to the plot. But speeding through them makes it feel disconnected.
I REALLY think this show should have been THREE seasons. Just to let the concepts and the ideas breathe, make it seem less rushed, and give more screen-time to the characters who ended up shortchanged. (I’m totally fine with them cutting the character of Thessaly though, because fuck Thessaly. Her role was absorbed by Nada and Joanna Constantine, which worked much better.) Ideally I think they could have combined A Game of You with the Season of Mists storyline, so that we could get Barbie and Wanda and the people of the boarding house (minus Thessaly) and an altered version of their story where they’re dealing with the returning of the dead from Hell instead of Barbie’s dream world, or maybe tie that dream world in with the returning people from Hell. We also REALLY needed more Cain, Abel and Matthew, who were seriously underused.
But I suppose it got too expensive, especially with Gaiman’s name being mud.
Pity that the adaptation ended up falling flat, really, because the Netflix series COULD have been the “ultimate” version of the Sandman story, the one that took the old story, polished it, updated it, smoothed out the rough edges, included more of what worked and fixed what didn’t work. There were plenty of good moments where the Netflix series DID improve on the original comic; Matthew’s introduction was a lot better, and Rose Walker was so much better in the series than the comic. I also liked this incarnation of the Endless; they were a dysfunctional family for sure, but they were somehow more likeable here. I still adore Mason Alexander Park’s Desire, who steals pretty much every scene they’re in, but I also liked how they made Delirium less “lolrandomcrazy” than she was in the comic while still making it clear she’s Not All There.
It was still worth watching, but it wasn’t the classic pondering and philosophical fantasy series with amazing characters it SHOULD have been. Oh well.
It’s kind of a shame because I can’t think of any modern fantasy quite like Sandman. I suppose the comic book version of Lucifer might come close, but frankly the characters are nowhere near as fun. And there’s the similarly Gaiman-penned American Gods, but honestly I didn’t actually like that book. The premise was okay, but the execution was just dull, and the characters were either unlikeable or uninteresting. I don’t know if the series is better because I had no interest in watching it.
And…. weirdly, this all means that Sandman has followed the Harry Potter trail. I mean, seriously, Sandman was always BETTER than Harry Potter and Gaiman is objectively a better writer than JKR… even when I was fangirling over both franchises I acknowledged that part… but now they both occupy the same strange space as franchises I used to adore but which have been irrevocably tainted by the actions of their creators. Franchises that used to bring me joy but no longer can in that same way. And they both held such a unique position in both pop culture and my heart that there just isn’t anything to replace them and fill the void they’ve left. (At least Tolkien’s Legendarium is safe, no matter how much Amazon tries to trample on it with Rings of Power. And they can’t touch my Terry Pratchett. But the list of franchises I still unabashedly adore is running short these days.)
Yes, I know, people are constantly going “just find another series and obsess over that instead!” but… there ISN’T one. I mean, there are plenty of fantasy series around and many of them are even really good. But none of them really fill the void. Works like Nevermoor and Stealing from Wizards and The Owl House try and partially succeed (I really should write a review of Stealing from Wizards here; those books were charming!) but… frankly, some of the series people push as “Harry Potter replacements” REALLY don’t work.
I mean, His Dark Materials?! By Philip FUCKING Pullman? Philip “I don’t write fantasy because fantasy is shallow and childish” Pullman?! The series that he wrote because the Narnia books were too preachy, and ended up TEN TIMES WORSE because the last book was just a long poorly-disguised rant about how religion sucks and fantasy is a waste of time? And an HBO series where every single actor except Lin-Manuel Miranda seems like they’ve had the instruction “act as if you’ve received the news that your best friend just died”? NO, I’m not going to even ACKNOWLEDGE that garbage.
And if Harry Potter is hard to replace, Sandman is impossible. Forget coming of age and magic schools, where else are you going to get anything that even remotely resembles that blending of mythology, dark fantasy, historical drama, and deeply philosophical musings on memory, storytelling, and change? Where can you find anything that matches its sheer narrative ambition, or its rich tapestry of mythic world-building where the great cosmic stories and the small personal ones get the same amount of weight? Sure, with all the fantasy written these days there MIGHT be something… maybe there’s some manga or some Franco-Belgian comic I haven’t discovered that manages… but honestly I’m not holding my breath. Because I have this feeling that… only Sandman can ever be Sandman. And Sandman is kind of lost to me. Not AS lost as Harry Potter, but still pretty damn lost.
I suppose I could try writing something myself, but I honestly don’t even know where to even start. And I probably would just end up writing lesbian mind-control porn anyway.